25 Best Cookie Butter Recipes (2024)

45 · Sep 4, 2018 · Updated April 17, 2022 · 4 Comments

So whether you are making something decadent for yourself or to give to someone else, this list is nothing short of mouthwatering ideas to enjoy! Heck, maybe you'll even win your office bake-off. Or give a kid some serious bragging rights. And aren't food gifts the best anyways?

Here are some ideas from around the web on how to use either the Speculoos cookies or the more famous spread cookie butter spread. You may see Biscoff mentioned too. Bottom line is, don't be afraid to experiment with those jars to turn them into something mouth-watering. You are already starting out with an amazing ingredient.

Below is my roundup of the 25 most awesome and mouthwatering ideas from around the web.

Drink Your Cookie Butter

But seriously though. Trader Joe's sells a solid cold brew. Why not make quite possibly the most decadent coffee creamer ever? Yes, Cookie Butter Coffee Creamer.

Read More

As a native NYer, there is a lot of internet buzz over Black Tap's Milkshakes. Why wait in line, when you can make something this outrageous at home?

Read More

Cookie Butter for Breakfast

Ok, maybe dessert for breakfast. I'm guilty of indulging in my fair share of Chocolate or Almond Croissants in the morning. But why haven't they thought of cookie butter croissants? Check out this 2 ingredient recipe for the croissant you didn't know you needed in your life.

If cinnamon rolls are too basic for you, then maybe cookie butter belongs on (and in) your cinnamon rolls too. Oh, and make that aPumpkin Cookie Butter Cinnamon Buns with Cookie Butter Glaze.

Cookie Butter as a Snack

No-Bake Biscoff Rocky Road squares keep it simple without losing that familiar rocky road goodness. White Chocolate. Marshmallows. Biscoff cookies. No baking required. Best of all, cut them up and they can be your afternoon indulgence. Nothing but sweet decadence.

I remember coming home from school and there would be Rice Krispies Treats. Those were the days. Even when they appeared in my lunch box it was a good day. How do you improve on a classic? Make them as Cookie Butter Rice Krispies Treats.

Once you've had homemade granola bars, there is almost no going back to the prepackaged stuff. Add some cookie butter and you've got quite the snack bar in your hands.

Five Minutes. Three Ingredients. It doesn't get easier or more delicious than this Speculoos Cookie Butter Popcorn recipe.

A happy place between a cookie and brownie must be a blondie right? Because snacking should satisfy like this Biscoff and White Chocolate Blondies.

If you adored the Cookie Butter and Chocolate Swirl, then this recipe might hold a special place for you. Chocolate and cookie butter play so well together, why not turn them into a swirled brownie? You can get the recipe here.

If you've enjoyed Trader Joe's Cookie Butter Cheesecake bites, then you know they are good. But we all know homemade is always better than store-bought. 7 ingredients, 5 steps to this easy Cookie Butter Cheesecake Bars.

No-Bake Ideas

Cookie Butter two ways: cookies and butter. Best of all, no baking is required. It's the easiest way to enjoy cheesecake's amazingness. You can get the recipe for this Biscoff No Bake Cheesecakehere.

Almost No-Bake Ideas

The crust needs a bake, but everything else just needs to chill. This pie would be stunning to present to someone. You can get the recipe for this (almost) No-Bake Cookie Butter Pie here.

Gift-Worthy Cookie Butter Ideas

No-bake. Picture perfect. Is there really a better gift than the homemade ones? Check out this No-Bake Cookie Butter Oatmeal Wreath Cookie recipes. Did I mention these are also gluten-free, egg-free, and can be made dairy-free?

How about picture-perfect AND vegan, soy-free and dairy-free? These pinwheel cookies are perfect for a party, bake sale, cookie swap, or just want stunning cookies to put out. Check out these Chocolate Biscoff Pinwheel Cookies recipes.

Imagine getting a few of these. I can't imagine a better way to be thanked than with theseEggless Cookie Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough balls. I mean c'mon cookie dough rules. You can check out the recipe here.

Some Like It Hot. From the Oven.

The smell of blondies is intoxicating. Add some cookie butter and some white chocolate will leave you with these decadent soft and chewy cookie butter blondies.

Let them eat cake? Nobody said you had to share. Check out this stunning Cookie Butter Cake recipe from Liv for Cake.

How do you make bread better? Use cookie butter and add a twist. You can get this Speculoos Butter Twist Bread by clicking the read more.

You had me at molten delicious cookie butter filling. At just 7 ingredients, 5 steps and it makes two servings. Perfect for date night or an extra dessert. After you finish the first one. You can check out the recipe here.

Some Like it Cold. The Best Chilled Recipes

If pudding is your thing, then you can elevate it with crushed Speculoos cookies in this Speculoos Tiramisu Pudding recipe which might be perfect for a gathering.

If you are feeling a little in need of chilled and over 21 desserts, then this recipe takes advantage of cream liqueur to make these Speculoos cookies even better. You can get the recipe here.

No fancy equipment is required to make these Homemade Cookie Butter and Chocolate Fudge Pops. As long as you have some plastic cups as molds you are ready to make these. And if you are wondering, yes these can be made vegan too.

The Bottom Line

Don’t forget toshare your thoughtsand leave a comment below.

You can alsoFOLLOW MEonFacebook,Instagram,Twitter, andPinterestto see what I’m up to.

45

Related